(From left: David Greenfield, Jonathan Judge, Joe Lazar, Avraham Shlomo Tischler. Photo credit: Brian Hedden)
The Jewish Press organized a debate last week with the participation of four of the candidates running for the empty 44th City Council seat (click here for their coverage). The Orthodox news site Vos Iz Neias had video produced of the entire two-hour function (their analysis is here). All 12 video clips are reposted below.
And of course, I was there as both a resident of the 44th, and as the South Brooklyn blogger!
One of the participating candidates – Avraham Shlomo Tischler – has already been dropped from the ballot, following successful challenges to the meager number of signatures on Tischler’s petitions.
The Daily News portrayed the 18-year-old Touro College student as the truth-to-power candidate, as some sort of modern-day David striking fear into the Goliath campaigns of David Greenfield and Joe Lazar. It’s stories like this that make it hard for me to take the Daily News seriously.
Tischler’s performance at the debate was beyond dismal – he definitively demonstrated that he was not, in any way, even remotely qualified for the job of City Councilman. He even said at one point, “I will have a well-trained staff that I know will guide me through each and every step of the way… I will learn becoming a Councilman the right and proper way” (video clip 4 below the fold, 6:05). Actually, he said that a lot. As if voters were somehow looking for an intern to fill the vacancy in the 44th.
As for the grown-ups in the room…
The core of Joe Lazar’s campaign has been to emphasize his experience in government (budget director at the DOB, regional director of the state’s mental health agency). During the debate, he specifically cited the experience and ability to delve into agency budgets, identify waste, and reappropriate the spending for worthwhile projects as his leading differentiator from the other candidates (video 3, 6:25).
What Lazar didn’t do was directly attack anyone else’s experience. In prior published reports, Lazar has basically said Greenfield lacks any relevant experience whatsoever. Last Wednesday, he settled for a call to the audience to vette out the statements of accomplishment made by himself and the others (video 4, 2:58).
Greenfield made sure to play up his most recent experience – founder of the education advocacy organization TeachNYS – and highlighted the accomplishments of that organization in winning funding in Albany for yeshivas and computers, and winning refundable tax credits for parents.
Jonathan Judge wants you to know he is a conservative Republican, and “the first and foremost priority of your next City Councilman has to be to make the cost of living in this city lower” (video 3, 4:05). He certainly got in the best zinger of the evening. When Greenfield railed against the high-profile endorsements for Lazar while failing to mention his own high-profile endorsements, Judge owned him in the response. “Both of the two colleagues sitting next to me have been endorsed by the very establishment people that left us with the massive corruption that we are dealing with right now… The people who are messimg up the system are trying to get more of the same people in it to join in the fun” (video 8, 7:45).
While Judge and Lazar emphasized identifying waste in the City budget, Greenfield made it clear his role would be one of community advocacy. “The role of the Councilman is not the role of the Mayor. We don’t manage the budget, we don’t write the budget, we don’t root out waste and fraud. There is one job that I have, and that is to demand more for this community, to bring the resources back and deliver to you” (video 4, 7:50). Lazar later replied that you have to work within existing funding streams during the economic downturn, and anyone who tells you they’re going to get you new programs “is out and out lying to you.”
And now, roll the tape…
P.S. Video 6 has a conversation about parking tickets that is far more interesting than you would ordinarily think.
Video 1 – Opening statements by David Greenfield and Jonathan Judge begin at 4:35.
Video 2 – Opening statements by Joe Lazar and Avraham Shlomo Tischler.
Video 3 – As a member of the city council you will be an integral part of the city’s budgetary process with both the Mayor and the Comptroller. You would have to find the proper balance of higher taxes and reduced spending, and find ways to help get our city through these difficult economic times. What makes you more qualified for this task than your opponents?
Video 4 – The City Council has 51 members and is often described as a body that functions by virtue of alliances among the members. What better suits you than your opponents for such coalitions? Additionally, you would be 51 out of 51 in seniority. How would you overcome this obstacle?
(Starting at 8:40) You all have talked about cutting expenses. Do you plan to push for any new programs on the City Council? If yes, how do you propose to pay for them? Please include in your answer the issue of increasing aid to yeshivas and other private schools.
Video 5 – (Starting at 6:30) – Audience question – …curious what your stance is on congestion pricing.
Video 6 – (Starting at 1:40) – Aside from writing a letter to the Commissionor, what other actions will you take to curb the problem of parking tickets?
Video 7 – What is your position on the lack of available housing in the district, and what specific steps would you take to address this problem? In your answer, please address the issue of affordable housing. Also, if you like, include the problem of the low number of public parks in the district.
Video 8 – Regarding issues such as gay rights, parochial schools, to the extent that they come before the City Council, should a Councilmember vote in accordance with his personal views, or the views of their constituents?
(Starting at 4:20) – Audience question – Many people think the system needs revamping. Many of you tout your experience in the system as the reason to vote for you. Don’t we really need people from outside the system to affect real change?
Video 9 – (Starting at 2:45) – A Jewish Press reader identifying himself as an Italian-American asked whether you would be able to represent all of the constituents in your district, and not just those from your own ethnic group?
Video 10 – Many of our Borough Park readers have expressed grievances concerning the lack of timely services in the community. Among their specifics have been poorly timed sanitation pickup, inadequate job of cleaning up the snow, especially this winter, and a litany of problems with the Access-A-Ride program. How would you fix any of these problems?
Video 11 – Closing comments – Avraham Shlomo Tischler, Joe Lazar, and Jonathan Judge
Video 12 – Closing comments – David Greenfield
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.